Because of these different lenses, the similarities and differences between sustainability and resilience become partially frameworkdependent. The definition of sustainability is not nearly as simple as it might seem, likewise with the definition of sustainable development. Sustainability was defined through the triple bottom line of environmental, social and economic system considerations. Sustainable development comprises the benefits of research and. It also acknowledges that shocks and stresses can reverse years of development gains.
According to the video the difference between sustainability and resilience, we feel was looked at in a totally different way than usually. The more advocacyoriented parts of the book will interest government. The yokohama strategy and plan of action for a safer world 1994, as the first major international framework for disaster risk reduction, recognized the interrelation between sustainable development and drr. The difference between sustainability and resilience. Mdgs were largely envisioned to be funded by aid flows, which did not materialize. With the 2015 deadline fast approaching, the united nations looks to build upon mdg progress by crafting an updated and inclusive post 2015 agenda.
The sdg is perhaps one of the most inclusive and participatory development processes the world has ever known, as it took a bottomsup approach. We draw conclusions concerning the sustainable management of ecologicaleconomic systemsinsection4. To evaluate its relevance to the theoretical relationship between resilience and sustainability, the 2019 u. Resilience, as a framework for understanding and approaching community development. Resilience is the practice of designing things to endure physical, social and economic shocks and stresses. Sustainability is the practice of reducing or eliminating environmental impact and improving quality of life for communities. What is the difference between resilience and sustainability, and which approach should you adopt. Mdgs did not include peace building in their core agenda and goals.
Environmental movement vs sustainable development resilience. Interplays of sustainability, resilience, adaptation and. By putting these city categories and their specific objectives next to each other and comparing them according to specific targets and achievements, we tend to forget the real opportunities smart city technologies offer. Sustainable urban development moved forward last year, when the. It then continues by elaborating on ways to approach and change our. Specifically, this chapter provides a summary of how these key paradigms and analytical. Resilience was viewed as the ability of a system to prepare for threats. Key differences between the concepts of sustainability and resilience. Managing risk and resilience for sustainable development presents the state of the world in relation to major sustainability challenges and their symptomatic effects, such as climate change, environmental degradation, poverty, disease and disasters. Resilience thinking is a complement to sustainability, not a substitute. Resilience must be embedded in the institutional, social, economic and environmental dimensions of sustainable development, in efforts at all levels to fight hunger and malnutrition. Sustainable development is a process in which natural resource base is not allowed to deteriorate. This extensive report characterizes and evaluates the. Rethinking urban sustainability and resilience chapter 7.
This is best illustrated by the fact that there are over 200 different definitions to what is sustainable development. If you wish to learn more on linkages between the work of the industrial accidents convention and the above global frameworks, see the information include webcast on the joint united uneceoecd seminar fostering implementation of the 2030 agenda for sustainable development and the sendai framework for disaster risk reduction 20152030 for. This briefing sheet explains the formation of the sdgs and examines factors that can contribute to or limit their success. Smart city solutions are a crucial step in the development of sustainable, resilient, and livable cities srl cities. Resilience thinking is therefore systems thinkingat least as much as sustainable development is.
Sustainability has been a core conceptual framework for community development since the approach was popularized in 1987, although in its essence it reflects a long history of environmental conservation reactions to industrialization. Relationship between humanitarian and development aid. What is the difference between resilience and mental toughness. Resilience is the ability to recover from a disaster that could have been prevented or mitigated with sustainable practices. World congress on resilience, from person to society, ebook, timisoara, 2014. We use a simple dynamic model where two natural capital stocks provide ecosystem services that are complements for human wellbeing, to illustrate different possible cases of the relationship between resilience and. This underpins the core message of the sustainable development goals sdgs that development is multifaceted and the achievement of many of the individual development goals is dependent on the accomplishment of other goals. Resilience february 26, 20 one comment rafe sagarin discusses the difference between adaptation and resilience in this answer to an audience question at the january 24, 2012 signature lecture for the centre for international governance innovation in waterloo, ontario, canada. Revisiting the resilience metrichow does it relate to. In it, the authors define sustainability as development that meets the needs of the present, without compromising the ability of future. Sustainability and resilience can work together in the economy, construction, transportation systems, systems of government and almost other system in existence. In this paper, we discuss the relationship between resilience and sustainability of ecologicaleconomic systems.
Its our responsibility as human beings to ensure that our businesses are as sustainable as possible, says jason hammond, chief commercial officer at. By lauren boucher may 1, 2015 time is almost up for the millennium development goals mdgs. Should sustainability and resilience be combined or remain. The sea gate project of new york harbor is used as a case study to demonstrate that ur and us can be contradictory.
Similarities and differences between community resilience. No doubt, our view of the kind and quality of cities we as societies want to build will continue to evolve and inspire a new descriptive goal. The video suggests that the idea of resilience is a more useful concept than the idea of sustainability and the idea of resilience comes from the study of ecology and it s really about how systems. It is also suitable for those who want to refresh or clarify existing knowledge.
Resilience thinking is therefore systems thinking at least as much as sustainable development is. Based on a yield difference between the control and the p treatments, 90% of sites responded to p fertilizer. Ordinarily speaking, it is a situation in which economic development does not decrease over time, sustainable development is the development that is everlasting. Why building resilience is the future of sustainable building. How to use and navigate this resource this is an introductory resource, targeted towards people who may be unfamiliar with how the concept of resilience is being applied in some international development contexts.
The green movement needs to focus more on resiliance. Resilience and sustainable development environment and. The book then investigates interrelations between sustainable and resilient building. The book starts with the exploration of the origin, development, and the. The brundtland reports popularization of sustainable development. Though there exist significant similarities between the millennium development goals launched in 2000 and the sustainable development goals launched in 2015, most notably in the quest to completely roll back poverty and hunger, though they both enjoy a further similarity in that they are clear, concise, timebound and measurable, there however, exist a number of differences between the two. Resilience in the sdgs overseas development institute.
In 1987, the united nations world commissions on environment and development published a report titled, our common future. Integration of the concept of sustainability into international, national and regional policies with multiple connections to urban development, began already in the late1980s. What is the difference between sustainability and building resilience. The articles and books referenced below are suggested reading for those interested in an overview of the relationships between ethics and sustainability. To be sustainable requires that stability is possible. However, the most common definition was defined by the brundtland commission in 1987, who documented the sustainable development definition as. In this appendix, we explore three ways of thinking about adaptation and its relationship with drr and development. The resilience agenda provides a common overarching framework for systematically linking and integrating risk reduction and crises management.
A major difference between the two development agendas is glaring when one looks at the processes that eventually lead to their adoption. This commitment was demonstrated by the signing of agenda 21, a global action plan on sustainable development. Nutrient use efficiency for food security, sustainable. In reality, natural and social systems behave in nonlinear ways, exhibit marked thresholds in their dynamics, and socialecological systems act as strongly coupled, complex and evolving integrated systems ibid. The pursuit of sustainability assumes that we a know what can be sustained and b have the capacity to maintain stationarity i. Application of p fertilizer increased wheat grain yield, up to 30% higher than the. Appendix b whats the difference between adaptation. The items here were chosen because of their relevance, accessibility, and availability all articles can be accessed online for free. Appendix b whats the difference between adaptation, disaster risk reduction and sustainable development.
Resilience is the word of the decade, as sustainability was in previous decades. Sustainability efforts are often understood on longer time scales than resilience. This chapter analyzes the complex interplays between and among sustainability, resilience, adaptation and transformation, key paradigms and analytical concepts that have emerged from the humanenvironmental interactions, socialecological systems, and global environmental change literatures. The regenesis group is a coalition of experienced design, landuse, planning, business, and development professionals who represent the forefront of the movement. The sustainable development goals sdgs, the centerpiece of the 2030 agenda for sustainable development, were adopted by the united nations sustainable development summit in september 2015. I became a convert to the idea that winwin solutions could be found by bringing all interests together around the same table. To distinguish between resilience and sustainability approaches, it is useful to contrast. Surely we have not lost our desire for sustainable cities, with footprints we can globally continue reading the cities we want. While the concept of sustainable development targets development which can at least in part avoid such changes and their negative consequences on people and the environment, resilience is about tackling and overcoming these changes without being completely overwhelmed by them. A conceptual framework is proposed to define the difference between ur and us. What is the difference between resilience and mental. The relevance of this concept for the problem of sustainable economic development has been recognized for at least fifteen years common and perrings, 1992.
Firstly, we use a game to illustrate how they can overlap and be. Table 2, below, outlines the many and major differences between resilience and sustainability. Weak sustainability has been defined using concepts like human capital and natural capital. Creating successful smart cities that are sustainable. That is why the principle of the disaster resilience is central to the 2030 agendas sustainable development goals. Managing risk and resilience for sustainable development aims to provide conceptual and practical approaches to sustainable development that help us to grasp and address uncertainty, complexity, ambiguity and dynamic change. Resilience and sustainable development european sustainable. Human and socialecological systems can build resilience through adaptation, mitigation, and sustainable development.
The difference between urban resilience ur and urban sustainability us are discussed. It is fair to say the sdg is unique in this respect. Four aspects that permeate our contemporary world and undermine much of our. The biggest difference is in the basic ontological assumptions about the nature of the world. The relationship between resilience and sustainability of. A key landmark was the rio summit in 1992 where the vast majority of nationstates committed themselves to sustainable development. Resiliency is being applied to psychology, urban design and even ecosystems and national security, but until now, it has not been used as a framework for investment planning. A high level of resilience is reflected in a high ri e value. A new, holistic transdisciplinary endeavour born in the 21 st century, sustainability science. Simply speaking sustainable development means the development which should keep going. Sustainability and resilience refer to two different. The quadruple bottom line strategy sustainable development goals series haris alibasic on.
I became aware of the emerging concept of sustainable development the idea that environmental, social, and economic priorities could be balanced. Why building resilience is the future of sustainable. Sdgs put sustainable, inclusive economic development at the core of the strategy. The relationship between resilience and sustainable. This has been recognized by several global documents on drr and sustainable development. One important difference between sustainability and resilience is the temporal scale of implementation. Managing risk and resilience for sustainable development.
944 1551 388 1323 134 1006 1036 802 711 1251 1528 11 1284 1167 539 1195 1322 427 1161 1555 672 206 548 1171 397 94 62 664